arcadiansinthetardiswithsherlock:
“Buffy the Vampire Slayer Week: Whedon’s Binary Excludes Bisexuality” by Erin Fenner
Willow is Whedon’s version of the answer to the underrepresented gay community. But, Willow appears to have had a healthy sexual relationship with her boyfriend Oz, and there is no hint at otherwise. She also pined for Xander for years. Both men. We see her gradually start a relationship with Tara, but she never talks about or reflects on her sexuality or coming out. We see that she is nervous about whether her friends approve. But, it doesn’t get much deeper than that. No characters have a deep conversation with her about her orientation. It’s not a thorough exploration. She goes from being with men to exclusively being with women and identifying as a lesbian. This is fine for Willow, but because there are really not many open gay or lesbian characters within the entire series we are dependent on her narrative alone.
I can appreciate Joss Whedon because he does write strong women. I think he did a lot for television but yes he is by no means perfect.
Willow going straight to gay was heartbreaking as a bisexual in the closet. I could recognize how this was a big step for lesbians but as a closet bisexual it was another thing that yet again made me feel there was something wrong with me. That what I’m feeling doesn’t actually exist and people are monosexual and therefore I’m some weird mutant that probably has some mental problem or something.
Even though I knew it wasn’t the case. But when I people don’t even entertain the idea non-monosexuality exists it just makes me feel like I’m some freak.
Willow was important for lesbians but she could have been just as important for bisexuals.
Joss won’t even really admit that his characters are bisexual. He just keeps saying they “experimented”.
Oh, yes, thank you. I remember being so excited when Willow and Tara started falling for each other, thinking, gosh this character is like me! She fell in love with men, and now she’s falling for a woman!
And then she just started calling herself gay… and that was heartbreaking for me in a way I can’t really explain. It was like the show was saying, no, people like you don’t really exist, how funny that you actually thought they could.
I'm From Seattle, WA
1.) I am a woman. 2.) I am married to a man. 3.) I work to defend queer youth rights and fight victimization. 4.) I am queer. 5.) I am bisexual. Most people hear the first two and assume that I am straight. They hear the third and wonder why a straight woman is working for the queer community. They hear the fourth and are confused. And when they hear the fifth, it all comes together in an eye roll. Bi-ignorance and bi-phobia are issues that I deal with every day of my life.
When I say that I am a woman, I mean female biologically and in my gender expression. On the continuum of gender expression, I mostly reside on the feminine side. I like to wear dresses with high heals, make-up and jewelry, carry a purse, shop at Victoria’s Secret, and get my nails done. There are of course the days that I am in men’s basketball shorts and wear my hair up to where it is shaved on the underside, but most people take one look at me and think that I am very feminine. When I first began working with queer youth, one of the questions I was asked was, “You don’t identify do you?” These kinds of assumptions followed me all the way to a date with a woman who actually asked me on the date if I were gay. I grew so tired of this that I decided I would change my appearance so that people could take one look at me and know that I was queer. I cut and buzzed my hair. I then had my nails taken off and I stopped wearing the dresses and carrying a purse. I completely altered how I looked, and it worked. I could walk into a room of queer people and no longer felt like an imposter. I was no longer asked questions of why I chose the line of work that I did. I felt completely accepted into the gay community. Only one problem, I hated to look in the mirror. I was feeling forced to express my gender in a way that was contrary to who I was, just to feel accepted. But even all that change to my gender expression was still not enough.
I could only get so far in the queer community based on my altered gender expression because it would all change the moment I said that I was bisexual. Once those words escaped by mouth, the bi-phobia from within the community would emerge. I had women not want to date me because I was tainted having been with a man. I was told that bisexuality did not exist; you were either one way or another. I stopped identifying as bisexual and started calling myself queer. I avoided ever talking about an ex-boyfriend and stopped seeing a lot of my straight friends. I felt like some sort of mutt, trying to hide my straight side and displaying only my gay pedigree. I couldn’t escape the bi-phobia. I would try to watch the L Word, hoping to see a bisexual character that I could identify with, but instead would watch her being asked to “make up her mind.” Several seasons later, she started identifying as a lesbian. I gave up the losing battle against other’s bi-phobia and realized the only thing left to do was fully embrace within myself being bisexual.
Embracing who I was felt good, and I started to date a wonderful woman who was supportive of my identity and encouraged me to put back on the dresses and high heals. I began to call myself bisexual again, this time with pride. I stopped thinking of myself in terms of my gay side and my straight side and realized that I was letting other’s perceptions cause me to divide myself. I came to realize that I wasn’t one-half gay, one-half straight, that I was all bisexual.
That relationship came to an end and the next person that I met was a man. Falling in love with and being in a serious relationship with a man brought back all of my insecurities. How could I bring him now into my queer world? He was fully accepting and wanted to go with me to my usual places, but I felt ashamed. I imagined eyes glaring at me, questioning me. It only got worse when he asked me to marry him.
Marriage was a hard decision for me. On one hand, it was a “no-brainer,” he was and is the love of my life. On the other hand, I felt like a hypocrite marrying when if by chance I had fallen in love with a woman, then marriage would not have even been an option. It was a long process to come to a place where I felt comfortable accepting the proposal. I discussed this at length with my queer family and friends. They told me that denying myself marriage, although a noble gesture, really did them no good. In fact, they said that they would rather see me happy and were glad that I had this opportunity. The general consensus was, why have one more suffering queer person out there if they don’t have to be? One optimistic friend told me that her time would be coming soon. A lesbian friend performed the marriage ceremony, and I felt as though I had the queer community’s blessing. All of my family and friends, both straight and gay, were there to help me celebrate.
Being married only added to my feelings of queer invisibility. When I talk about my husband, everyone assumes that I am straight. Add that to my feminine gender expression, and there is no doubt in anyone’s mind. I actually had a queer coworker complain to me that she was the only queer person at our work. I find myself wanting to scream out in meetings or in circles of new friends, “I’m queer!” It is funny because one of the criticisms I have heard of bisexuals is how easy we can blend into heterosexual society. If only those who made such statements knew how desperate I am to not fit in, to be noticed and recognized for who I am.
And who I am is bisexual. When I was with girlfriends, I was bisexual. Currently married to my husband, I am still bisexual. From my morning shower to brushing my teeth at bedtime, I am bisexual. It was never a phase, never a thing I did in college, never something for fun. It isn’t an identity that I tried on like a party hat. It was and is who I am. I don’t need to make up my mind. My mind, heart, body, and soul have been made up for a long time. I am bisexual.
I recently said to a young girl who proudly exclaimed that she is bisexual to be prepared, that it is a hard road. I hope that when she reaches my age, the bi-ignorance and bi-phobia will have dissipated. In the meantime, I will strive to educate all those whom I come in contact with that a person can be 1.) A woman. 2.) Married to a man. 3.) Work to defend queer youth rights and fight victimization. 4.) Queer. 5.) Bisexual.
not my post; this was answered by themusethatgrewfromboredom regarding heteronormality. I’ve asked if I could reblog it and so I made it rebloggable and available for everyone to read.
Usually I respond to stupidity and ignorance with condescension, but your pompousness and arrogance pissed me off to no end. So I’m going to give you a fucking bitch-mode reply.
Here’s a PS fucking A for a dumb fucking anon, and dumb fucking people who think like him/her.
- A woman is capable of falling for another woman even if she loved a man.
- A woman is capable of falling for another woman even if she loved a man.
- A WOMAN IS CAPABLE OF FALLING FOR ANOTHER WOMAN EVEN IF SHE LOVED A MAN.
BISEXUALITY EXISTS.
BISEXUALITY EXISTS.
BISEXUALITY FUCKING EXISTS!
In this fucking society you are considered straight till proven gay. You know why? Because it’s the NORM to be straight. That’s where the term,heteronormality comes from. Just because that is what society thinks, doesn’t make it fucking right.
A woman can like dick, and still be attracted/fall in love with women and that is fine.
A woman can like dick, and be attracted/fall in love with only men and that is fine.
A woman can like vagina and only be attracted to women and that is fine.
A show is capable of embracing bisexual characters in their shows without devaluing their former relationships of the opposite sex. A show doesn’t have to show any implications of a woman having feelings for a woman in the fucking Pilot episode.
Not everyone is intuned with their sexuality at a young age.
You are fully capable of discovering.
It is not an unconventional thing.
I mean
It
HAS
Happened
BEFORE!
Do I
Need
to
Go on?!
Also let me fucking point out that the last two pictures aren’t fictional. Cynthia Nixon, who you might fucking know as fucking Miranda Hobbs in Sex in the City, was married to a man for fifteen fucking years, and they had a fucking child together. But now she is fucking Married to Christine Marinoni and they have fucking children together.Does that demean or devalue her relationship with her ex husband? No. Does that demean or devalue her relationship with her current wife? No!
So please, fucking anon, don’t give me that ‘they’re straight’ bullshit because I will squash that shit with the quickness. There are quite a few reasons why someone would not ship swan queen, like there are quite a few reasons not to ship any couple, BUT SEXUALITY SHOULD NOT BE ONE OF THEM BECAUSE YOUR DICK DOESN’T DEFINE MY SEXUALITY!
Now please, anon, go fuck a walrus!
Also, this goes out for males as well. Males, despite the general population and even some in the LGBTQ community may think, are capable of being bisexual as well. I did not forget that. I’m just speaking of this particular subject involving women.
A reminder that who I’m dating does not erase my identity as a bi woman.
In 1971 Petty Officer Robert A. Martin Jr. became the first US Servicemember to publicly fight his discharge for being a LGBTQ person. Said journalist Randy Shilts in his 1993 book Conduct Unbecoming: Gays and Lesbians in the US Military,
In the tens of thousands of hearings since World War II where comparable actions had been taken on the basis of comparable evidence, the matter ended there, with the sailor skulking away in disgrace. Petty Officer Martin, however, went public with what had happened to him and swore to fight for an honorable dischargeDespite the support, he received a general discharge in 1972, but he continued to fight and in 1977 his discharge was upgraded to “honorable”. wrote historian David Eisenbach in his 2006 book Gay Power: An American Revolution,
Martin’s groundbreaking public battle against the Navy kicked off a series of well-publicized challenges to military discharges that harnessed and directed the energy of the gay rights movement in the 1970s.Despite the words gay, gay , gay being endless thrown about Petty Officer Martin, (who is better known by his nom de guerre Stephen Donaldson and his pen name Donny the Punk) is a famous and important bisexual activist.
Though he did die just short of his 50th birthday (yes from AIDS, in many ways he completely epitomized the “sex and drugs and rock-and-roll” lifestyle of his era with all it’s excesses, pitfalls and it’s joyousness) he had an amazingly full life and quite the wild ride. In 1966 he founded the first LGBTQ Student Group, he was an active member in the Gay Liberation Front (GLF) & Gay Activists Alliance (GAA) the groups that sprang to life immediately the day after the Stonewall Riots and most famously in 1972 he helped draft the Quaker Committee of Friends “Ithaca Statement on Bisexuality”, perhaps the earliest public expression of a new bisexual consciousness.
more stuff all bisexual/non-monosexual people should know
The Kinsey Chronicles: The Top Five Bisexual News Stories of 2012
2012 was a significant year for bisexual visibility. The bisexual movement reached a new level of maturity with many bisexual organizations celebrating around a quarter century of existence.
- Bisexuals Gained Visibility and Respect as Elected Official
- Bisexual Activists Pushed Back on Attacks on The Word Bisexual
- Bisexual Pride Day (September 23) Gained Greater Official Recognition
- The International Bisexual Movement Expanded
- High Profile Bisexual People Came Out of The Closet or Re-affirmed Their Bisexuality When Questioned
(Source: facebook.com)
Gaelick: On being a bisexual with a boyfriend
Ms. Gay Limerick is bisexual and has been blogging about it in the Irish lesbian blog Gaelick —
“I have been dating my best friend for the last month. My best friend is a boy. Before anyone starts throwing stones of “passing”, “straight privilege”, “heteronormativity,” or “attention seeking skank”, hear me out.
There is little point in trying to deny that parts of the queer community are rife with biphobia. I dealt with it a lot with Ms Gay Limerick and even more with Ms Gay Ireland. For the year and a half I have been out, I am very careful what I say to certain people. Sometimes it feels like the more political and vocal I get about bisexual identity, the more backlash I seem to get.
Previous to dating the current boy, I was very hush hush about my romantic life to anyone outside my best friends and my mom. I didn’t want the LGBTQ circle to find out I was flirting with boys, I didn’t want my straight friends to know I was shifting girls. I became overly conscious of avoiding gender pronouns and did all I could to avert the inevitable slut shaming that tends to follow bisexuals around. I even censored myself when writing Gaelick articles so I could be sure there would be no flaming.
Finally, there came a point when I realised that I was acting like I was still in the closet. In the same way I used to hide that I loved the ladies, I was now ashamed of not being gay enough.”
(Source: twitter.com)
Unlike some *ahem* other parts of the Queer Nation the Bisexual Community doesn't ditch people when convenient . . .
Then President of BiNet USA Wendy Curry said it best when the Bisexual Community refused to go along with too many in the the mainstream Gay/Lesbian establishment and ditch Trans*/GenderQueer people to try and get Equal Rights for just Cisgender Heteronormative/Homonormative people back in 2007 —
The trans community is part of the bi “net.” Unlike other national groups, we will not discard “inconvenient” parts of our community in order to win a political victory. Likewise, we would never consider tossing out the polyamourous, the monogamous, the pagan, or the christians; our diversity makes us strong …
The people who wish to “shave off” gender identity and the same people who, when necessary, will remove bisexuals from marriage, military, or any other civil rights actions. We’re too complicated. We distract from the “core” issue …
Sure, I’d love to live in a country where I couldn’t be fired for being out. But not if I had to look a transgender friend in the eye and tell them they weren’t convenient.. that it’s not their time.
It’s not about “those people” making things difficult (unless by those people, you mean the ones willing to ditch gender identity and divide the BLTG community). This is an attack on the bi community directly. Whether it’s about your gender identity, (one of) your partner’s, or your future partner - it all comes down to the right to be employed should not be given based on any one’s gender.
A wise person once said “United we stand, divided we fall”. There was no mention of when it’s “convenient.”
UPDATE: Continuation Granted for Polish Journalist threatened with Deportation by the USA for being Bisexual
On Monday, December 17, 2012, the case of bisexual Polish journalist Ivo Widlak and his bisexual Hispanic-American wife Lale was extended until December 12, 2013. The judge in Ivo’s case has made no decisions, so the case will remain under investigation by USCIS.Even thought Ivo & Lale have been married since September 2002, in July 2009 after Ivo exposed some corruption in one of his articles, the US Government declared their marriage to be a fraud since they Ivo & Lale are both openly bisexual and moved to deport Ivo back to Poland.Ivo’s attorney Ira Azulay says, “We (and I) believe that USCIS is far too restrictive in the way they interpret the immigration laws. Anytime we see people being badgered by the system, we believe that we can help them push back. The system for too long has counted on people giving up, and that just should not be the result.”We must thank the Bisexual Community, (in particular American Institute of Bisexuality (AIB), BiNet USA, the Bisexual Queer Alliance Chicago and the Chicago Bisexual Queer Meetup) as well as our Lesbian/Gay & Straight-But-Not-Narrow allies (in particular National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR) and Immigration Equality).
However we must again note with sadness those few (and we sincerely hope! getting fewer) in the mainstream Gay/Lesbian community who letting prejudice, misunderstanding and their personal antipathy towards Bisexual people override the best interests of the entire LGBTQ Community as well as common decency tried to use their positions of (relative) power when they publicly allied themselves with those who deny the existence of bisexual people and even went so far as to try and expand the meaning of DOMA to have this marriage declared invalid and the deportation continued.
Yet AGAIN we must ask where is all that “Heterosexual Privilege” that All Bisexual People are rurmored to have?
Things To Do:
THANK YOU EVERYONE + Keep Up the Good Work, this Would NOT Have Happened Without You
- KEEP WELL INFORMED - read the Original Story: Polish journalist to be deported due to his bisexuality of 12 December 2012 and the Update: The Curious Case of Ivo Widlak of 19 December 2012 by BiNet USA’s president Faith Cheltenham
- Don’t let this be forgotten, the US Government tried to do this in Silence & Secret. So reblog, share, tweet and signal boost
- Go to your GSA, your SAGA’s, your LGBT Centers, all the LGBTQ Groups you give your money and time too. Make sure they Know All About this. Show them the actual definitions of Bisexuality. Make sure they stop making snide jokes about how Bisexuals all have “Privilege” … about how we are all just “in the closet” … how we are binary and transphobic and all the other sly digs and daily erasure we suffer. Make them listen to us and see us and include us.
- If you are in the USA please join the BiNet USA Group on Facebook
- If you are in Chicagoland please join on Facebook: Bisexual Queer Alliance Chicago + Chicago Bisexual Queer Meetup on Meetup: Chicago Bisexual / Queer Community
- And remember to watch this and the other Bisexual Blogs to keep up with what is going on in YOUR Community.
Do NOT let anyone tell you that Electronic Activism is worthless. They are just trying to get you all to shut-up and go away. Do NOT let anyone tell you that Bisexuals are “too complicated”, are a distraction from “core” Gay/Lesbian issues and that anyway Bisexuals will get your “rights” after the mainstream Lesbian/Gay get theirs. This is what (some) cynical and selfish groups/people say about Trans* issues to! And we’ve ALL seen how well THAT works.
Without Each and Everyone of YOU Ivo & Lale would be in separate countries Right Now instead of home together for Christmas.
Amen!!!
What does it mean to be bisexual? It’s simple actually —
Bisexuals = people who can ♥ people of same gender as themselves + can ♥ people of different genders/gender presentations from themselves
Dear disgruntled player,
I find it difficult to believe that you are truly troubled by the perception that all LIs are bisexual. I know you have wrapped up your rhyme and reason in statements about realism, even providing some unsourced percentages as “fact,” but I personally find that to be a shallow argument.
I’ve seen you ask for overt signs, for declarations, so that you might know which way those characters swing, though you may not have used that exact phrase. I’ve seen you make assumptions about how a character might identify his/herself based solely on dialogue or some circumstantial clues, or on your own skewed concept of what it means to be gay, although you have never experienced any game sequence where the PC could ask the LI how he/she would define his/herself.
Find out that someone might be gay, and you may immediately think “hm, he/she does not behave like gays in media, or the gays that I know.” Sure, that might throw you for a loop. But the fact is, people are different, people are unique, people do not always wear their sexual identity on their sleeves, and even if they do, how that aspect manifests itself is not always in line with some trope.
I think this is all reactionary. I think that when you cite lack of realism, what you are trying to say is that you are uncomfortable with the idea, the concept…nay, the mere existence of people who might consider themselves bisexual. After all, what does bisexual mean? Or rather, what does it mean to you and how it affects your life?
This hearkens to those individuals who can’t quite get over the fact that their romantic partner has had an emotional and/or sexual relationship with someone of the same gender in their past. As a straight woman, does the fact that your boyfriend slept with another guy once or twice before bother you? As a straight man, does the fact that your girlfriend slept with another woman disturb you?
To that, I ask, why does it matter? Is a person to be judged solely on the relations of their past? Should we assess current or future lovers by a ratio of who they have been with in the years gone by? “Of the last 10 partners, how many were male, how many were female? Now take an average…” Is a tally of lovers something to supersede if a person is kind, or honest, or witty, or any number of qualities that speak more about the core of the person?
Perhaps, disgruntled player, you think that sexuality/sexual identity is a choice, and therefore you equate bisexuality as some sort of inconsistency, some sort of fence-straddling. A person who either can’t decide, or decides based solely on convenience. Perhaps you see that individual as someone who must be promiscuous, because clearly, the ability to sleep with both men and women must hearken to some sort of depravity, some sort of hedonism. It is the stuff of Roman bacchanalians, of orgies, of wanton behavior. Right?
To that, I would say you are grossly wrong. Human desire and affection are driven by a multitude of factors, a grand array that takes from genetic code and chemistry. But it is also driven by our backgrounds and upbringings, in that we feel able and willing to embrace who we are, once we have a handle on who that person is (and for some, this is a perpetual struggle).
Why then, are you so willing to judge and dismiss someone who simply is different from you? Because you can’t understand what makes them tick? Because you never took the time to try to understand, to view things from another perspective, to accept someone for the whole and total person that they are? Is it just easier instead to force someone into a compartment and category?
Claim that something is unrealistic, and you minimize its legitimacy. You declare it to be preposterous, fake, and false. And so when you cry foul over what may be four bisexual individuals in a game, or in a group of seven or so friends, you essentially spit upon those people for whom that is indeed a reality. You deny their existence, you laugh at it.
Maybe it’s not your reality, disgruntled player, what you are familiar with. Maybe it’s going to take some time to wrap your head around things - that the world may not work in the way that you have long believed it to. That people do not spawn out of five or six predefined molds. That people are so much more than the notches on their bedpost. That love might be more powerful than you know.
I just wish you’d come out and say it - that you’re uncomfortable or uneasy. That what truly bothers you is not some supposed fanservice or pandering or whatever crap claim you want to make, but that you don’t know, yet, how to reconcile these differences.
You might be fearful to admit your discomfort (something else that you might not be wholly willing to confess to). And that’s understandable. But perhaps if you did, perhaps if you said “this doesn’t seem right to me,” you might open up a whole new conversation that could provide a new perspective. Not necessarily to convince you, but to broaden your viewpoint. To have an exchange of words and ideas that occurs with some decency and politeness, instead of round after round of bitter and reactive ire. Maybe then, you might see why some game options and features are important to other people…and why we might see them as perfectly, and reasonably, realistic.
Sincerely,
- a fellow player
A Double Life: Bisexual Bias in the Gay Community
“If you say you’re gay, very few people say, ‘Well, what do you mean?’ Bisexuals have to come out every time they walk into a room … I get it from both communities. We like to joke that’s the one thing straights and gays agree on: They don’t understand bisexuals” …
… . When the bigotry comes from the straight community, it’s hurtful. But when it comes from the gay community, it’s worse—because they should understand. This is the experience of the gay community—having the straight community tell them they’re wrong, they don’t exist. For me, it feels like personal betrayal. I feel like ‘I was there with you, in the beginning,’ and then I hear ‘What has bisexuality done for the movement?’ That just floors me. The history has been rewritten.” ~Denise Ingram
Ingram, 41, grew up in Jamaica—where being anything other than straight is punishable with jail time but is more often handled by mob violence—and she spent the ’80s and ’90s advocating for gay rights in New York City, where she identified as a lesbian before coming out as bisexual. Ingram met her husband of three years, James Klawitter, at a meeting of BiUnity, a Philly-based bisexual support network.
She feels connected to the LGBT community—entitled to the connection even—and she remembers the times when no one in the movement was accepted by the mainstream, when no one thought to check her gay credentials …
Linda A. Hawkins is a counselor and research coordinator at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, where she works with LGBT youth. She previously worked as a counselor at the Attic Youth Center and sees some gold at the end of this rainbow. But even in her field, she says, there were sometimes issues among colleagues when she disclosed her bisexuality (she’s in a long-term committed relationship with a woman—who, yes, also initially had some reservations about dating someone who’s bisexual).
But what Hawkins—and nearly every other person interviewed for this article—has found is that the kids, or at least the younger generation, seem to have a lot fewer hang-ups about being bi, gay, gender non-conforming or whatever. “I see more acceptance from youth,” she says. “I’ve worked with young people for the last 15 years in Philadelphia, and I can tell that the flexibility around gender and sexuality has expanded. And that leads to kids being more accepting of themselves, of others and of bisexuality.”
Sometimes, other people may be too narrow-minded to understand you, but that doesn’t change who you are! Do what feels right for you and makes you happy!
(Source: boggletheowl)












